Curious Christian

Reflections on culture, nature, and spirituality from a Christian perspective

McLaren On Other Religions

In his book, The Church on the Other Side, Brian McLaren writes:

“One of the toughest challenges in the church on the other side will be to develop a new way of talking about – and with -other religions.”

I would like to kick off this new site by inviting the emergent church to seriously consider this challenge posed by Brian.

McLaren points out that globalization is reshaping, not only the world, but our local communities:

“To dismiss Buddhism when all Buddhists lived on the other side of the world was easy; but when a Buddhist lives next door or teaches your college chemistry class and proves to be a good neighbour or professor, his beliefs are not so easily dismissed.”

I find this an interesting comment, as I do in fact live next door to a Buddhist. She is a dear old lady who has recently been widowed.

But that’s just the beginning.

On the other side of our house are a young family of Sikhs who’s one year old daughter plays with my son. Two doors further up is a young Hindu family, who’s son also plays with my son. The world is at our doorstep – literally. Yet the majority of Christians I speak to, even in my local area, have a curious resistance to direct two-way dialogue with people from other religions. Despite years of trying to encourage Christians to engage, behavioural change has been meager. It is indeed a great challenge.

Is my area so unique? Yes and no. It is true we are in a hot spot for Hinduism, but other areas have their own demographic quirks. We’re not THAT unique. In my experience it have more to do with willingness to set outside your comfort zones. You don’t see what you shy away from.

McLaren continues:

“To caricature all Muslims as terrorists is easy until you meet a Muslim of grace and ethical depth. To focus on the cruelties of some Hindus and in so doing dismiss Hinduism might work until a Hindu points out a few of our own embarrassments and egregious failures as Christians. Just as we must acknowledge that both kooks and saints stand under the Christian banner, we will have to stop giving ourselves permission to be prejudiced and stereotypical about members of other religions. We can’t keep comparing our best with their worst and feeling smug.”

As a person who is deeply committed to justice and truth I find the vilification of other religions by Christians to be most disturbing. In our previous house we lived next door to a Muslim family. I became friends with the husband, Mohammed, and he was one of the best and most gentle neighbours I’ve ever had. Yet again and again Christians characature Muslims as violent. Only recently a pair of Christian ministers were found guilty in Melbourne, Australia for incitement to religious hatred. It sickens me that this is allowed to continue within the ranks of the contemporary church. One of my great hopes for the emerging church is that it can rise to the challenge of being good Samaritans to our neighbours.

2 responses to “McLaren On Other Religions”

  1. Mal Avatar
    Mal

    I don’t remember all the words to the Hymns we sung at Chapel at School, but the one ‘Thine be the Glory’, from memory, mentioned victory over death. Not turbans, sari’s, teatowels or the opposition footy club.
    The focus on seeking difference rather than similarities between religions and beliefs feeds division among communities and eventually within churches.
    I do not purport to have any theological knowledge worth mentioning, and that is perhaps why I can see what many within the Church cannot.
    Having grown up with Uniting Church teachings, perhaps their more moderate view would not go astray in the more ‘established’ churches.

    Like

  2. philjohnson Avatar

    Perhaps the tensions on this comprise:
    1. The uniqueness, particularity and finality of God’s revelation in Christ as saviour;
    2. The unwitting tendency that makes the incarnation and redemption look like a comic book hero story of Jesus like superman who rescues us (Lois Lane) and flies us off to heaven.
    3. My 2nd point leads on to the outcome that this unwitting tendency divorces incarnaion/redemption from the sphere of the creation.
    4. The uniting factor is the creation – we belong in the creation as God’s appointed stewards to care for everything; and so we bear the imago dei, but it is now fractured and incomplete.
    5. While it is important to distinguish between the uniqueness of Jesus and redemption in him from the remedies prescribed in other pathways, noting those differences ought not to be construed as the licence to deny the essential humanity of others. By creating the “alien other” or typecasting others as “the enemy”, Christians do a serious disservice to Christ, the good news, and ultimately to themselves and to those they dismiss or despise. Perfect love casts out fear — how much of evangelical angst about other religions is bounded by fear and ignorance and a corresponding lack of charity and a lack of biblical understanding on how to cope and survive and thrive in a pluralist world?

    Like

Leave a comment